Show the map
Get to know
Bay Shore
32
APARTMENTS
1
NEIGHBORHOODS
Rent Trends for Apartments in Bay Shore
September 2025
| Bedroom count | Bay Shore | vs Last Month |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | $2,279 |  down 0.91% |
| 1 Bedroom | $2,477 | down 6.53% |
| 2 Bedroom | $2,955 | down 1.47% |
| 3 Bedroom | $3,650 | down 1.35% |
| 4 Bedroom | $5,000 | — |
Median rent as of August 31, 2025
This September, we've analyzed our 32 listings in Bay Shore to determine the rent trend. We're updating our tables in real time to give you the most up to date Bay Shore median apartment rent prices by bedroom count.
Cities Near Bay Shore
Apartment Types in Bay Shore
Find Your Dream Apartment for Rent in Bay Shore
PadMapper has 32 condos, houses, and apartments for rent in Bay Shore. Specifically, 4 studio apartments, 12 one-bedroom apartments, 4 two-bedroom apartments, 5 three-bedroom apartments are currently available for rent.
We have options to filter by price, bedroom count, bathroom count, long-term or short-term, housing type, pet friendly, no broker fee, and you can search for an apartment by custom keywords.
Bay Shore NY Apartments for Rent
Rent
Edit
Length
Bedrooms
Save
More Filters
Online tours
$2,025–$3,120
Studio–2 Bedrooms Apartments · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Mid Island Apartments 35 Penataquit Ave is an apartment rental building with 6 floorplans, and studio–2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has building amenities including outdoor space, on-site laundry, and on-site management. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
$2,625–$3,125
Studio–1 Bedroom Apartments · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Eleven Maple 11 Maple Ave is an apartment rental building with 2 floorplans, and studio–1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has building amenities including roof deck, outdoor space, and fitness center. View building
Online tours
$2,250–$2,750
Studio–1 Bedroom Apartments · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Village Place 61 W Main St is an apartment rental building with 3 floorplans, and studio–1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has building amenities including on-site laundry. View building
$2,600
1 Bedroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
1 East Main 1 E Main St is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has building amenities including fitness center, business center, and on-site laundry. View building
$2,975
1 Bedroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
North District Lofts 57 Park Ave is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View building
$2,464–$2,800
1 Bedroom Apartments · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Greenview Square Charleys Pl is an apartment rental building with 2 floorplans, and 1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View building
Online toursIncome restricted
$2,464
1 Bedroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Greymore Flats 19 N Clinton Ave is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View building
$2,075
1 Bedroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
28 5th Ave #A is a 1 bedroom, 0 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment
$3,400
3 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
155 5th Ave is a 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space. View apartment
Short stay
$6,800
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
91 S Penataquit Ave #NA is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space, and swimming pool. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$4,200
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
39 Redmond Ave is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and outdoor space. View apartment
New Construction
$2,550
1 Bedroom · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
1820 4th Ave is a 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment
$4,800
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
21 Rhodes Ave is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including garage parking. View apartment
$3,600
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
153 5th Ave is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space. View apartment
$5,000
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
53 5th Ave is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including on-site laundry. View apartment
$2,500
2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
10 Spruce St is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment
$5,000
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
39 Midway Walk is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment
New Construction
$7,500
4 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
44 Island Walk is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including on-site laundry. View apartment
$1,000
1 Bedroom · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
25 Belford Ave 2nd Fl #1 is a 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment
New Construction
$16,000
8 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
100 E Lighthouse Walk is a 8 bedroom, 4 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. View apartment