Show the map
Get to know
Shelter Island
6
APARTMENTS
Rent Trends for Apartments in Shelter Island
September 2025
| Bedroom count | Shelter Island | vs Last Month |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | $50,000 | No change |
| 1 Bedroom | $30,000 | No change |
Median rent as of August 31, 2025
This September, we've analyzed our 6 listings in Shelter Island to determine the rent trend. We're updating our tables in real time to give you the most up to date Shelter Island median apartment rent prices by bedroom count.
Cities Near Shelter Island
Apartment Types in Shelter Island
Find Your Dream Apartment for Rent in Shelter Island
PadMapper has 6 condos, houses, and apartments for rent in Shelter Island. Specifically, studio apartments, one-bedroom apartments, two-bedroom apartments, 2 three-bedroom apartments are currently available for rent.
We have options to filter by price, bedroom count, bathroom count, long-term or short-term, housing type, pet friendly, no broker fee, and you can search for an apartment by custom keywords.
Shelter Island NY Apartments for Rent
Rent
Edit
LengthÂ
Bedrooms
Save
More Filters
Verified
$4,000
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
9 Johnston Road is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space. Â View apartment
$30,000
4 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
15 S Cartwright Rd is a 4 bedroom, 4 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including residents lounge, garage parking, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
$40,000
4 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
18 Xxxxxx Dickerson Drive is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
$50,000
3 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
28 Gardiners Bay Drive is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, on-site laundry, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
$25,000
3 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
5 Bay Rd is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
$75,000
6 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms Apartment · Shelter Island, NY
5+ Days Ago
15 Montclair Ave is a 6 bedroom, 4 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Shelter Island. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool. Â View apartment
Verified
$35,000
7 Bedrooms · 9 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
2524 Noyac Rd is a 7 bedroom, 9 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool, garage parking, and on-site laundry. Â View apartment
Verified
$4,500
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
4315 Noyac Rd is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool. Â View apartment
Verified
$18,000
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · East Hampton, NY
5+ Days Ago
11 N Cape Ln is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in East Hampton. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool, and outdoor space. Â View apartment
Verified
$50,000
6 Bedrooms · 6 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
29 Bittersweet Ln is a 6 bedroom, 6 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including residents lounge, swimming pool, outdoor space, and on-site laundry. Â View apartment
Verified
$45,000
4 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
28 Windermere Dr is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including residents lounge, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
Verified
$20,000
5 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms Apartment · East Hampton, NY
3 Days Ago
2 Great Oak Way is a 5 bedroom, 4 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in East Hampton. It has apartment amenities including on-site laundry, swimming pool, garage parking, residents lounge, and outdoor space. Â View apartment
Verified
$45,000
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
30 Sunset Rd is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool, outdoor space, on-site laundry, and roof deck. Â View apartment
Verified
$40,000
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
68 W Water St ##Unit is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including residents lounge, outdoor space, storage, and swimming pool. Â View apartment
Verified
$30,000
2 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
23 Marjorie Ln is a 2 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and outdoor space. Â View apartment
Verified
$25,000
5 Bedrooms · 6 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
156 Main St is a 5 bedroom, 6 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool, and outdoor space. Â View apartment
Verified
$70,000
4 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · East Hampton, NY
2 Days Ago
643 Stephen Hands Path is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in East Hampton. It has apartment amenities including swimming pool, garage parking, and outdoor space. Â View apartment
Verified
$20,000
4 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
17 Emerson Pl is a 4 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and swimming pool. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
Verified
$8,000
2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Sag Harbor, NY
5+ Days Ago
10 Wickatuck Dr is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in Sag Harbor. Â View apartment
Verified
$8,000
3 Bedrooms · 3 Bathrooms Apartment · Southold, NY
5+ Days Ago
355 Midway Rd is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in Southold. Â View apartment
That's All Folks!
We’re out of listings matching your filters. Want more results?
Modify Filters  or  Start a New Search