36 Jay Rd · Apartment for Rent

Rental Registry#: 26-515 Once the home of Irving Berlin's musical partner and currently belonging to the musician Rufus Wainwright, this beach cottage exudes the aura of creativity a peaceful retreat by the ocean inspires. Sitting privately in the Hither Hills area of Montauk, this 2 bedroom/1 bath original Leisurama house has a decidedly modern and chic 50's sensibility. There are lovely grounds, fully fenced, with an oversized deck, a secreted outdoor shower, a new sauna and outdoor hot tub. Above the separate garage is a large studio and full bath, complete with Rufus' first piano...perfect for any overflow summer may bring. This secluded property is a mere mile from the festivities, shops and restaurants of lively Montauk. Proprietary key enables access to the nearby Hither Hills Ocean Beach area making ocean parking and access available to the tenant. Updated 2026.