Show the map
Get to know
Bay Shore
32
APARTMENTS
1
NEIGHBORHOODS
Rent Trends for Apartments in Bay Shore
September 2025
| Bedroom count | Bay Shore | vs Last Month |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | $2,279 |  down 0.91% |
| 1 Bedroom | $2,477 | down 6.53% |
| 2 Bedroom | $2,955 | down 1.47% |
| 3 Bedroom | $3,650 | down 1.35% |
| 4 Bedroom | $5,000 | — |
Median rent as of August 31, 2025
This September, we've analyzed our 32 listings in Bay Shore to determine the rent trend. We're updating our tables in real time to give you the most up to date Bay Shore median apartment rent prices by bedroom count.
Cities Near Bay Shore
Apartment Types in Bay Shore
Find Your Dream Apartment for Rent in Bay Shore
PadMapper has 32 condos, houses, and apartments for rent in Bay Shore. Specifically, 4 studio apartments, 12 one-bedroom apartments, 4 two-bedroom apartments, 5 three-bedroom apartments are currently available for rent.
We have options to filter by price, bedroom count, bathroom count, long-term or short-term, housing type, pet friendly, no broker fee, and you can search for an apartment by custom keywords.
Bay Shore NY Pet Friendly Apartments for Rent
Rent
Edit
Length
Bedrooms
Save
More Filters
Online tours
$2,025–$3,120
Studio–2 Bedrooms Apartments · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
Mid Island Apartments 35 Penataquit Ave is an apartment rental building with 6 floorplans, and studio–2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has building amenities including on-site management, outdoor space, and on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
Short stay
$6,800
4 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Bay Shore, Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
91 S Penataquit Ave #NA is a 4 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Bay Shore neighborhood of Bay Shore. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space, and swimming pool. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$3,800
3 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Deer Park, Deer Park
4 Hours Ago
33 Maida Avenue is a 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Deer Park neighborhood of Deer Park. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$4,995
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · Islip, Islip
3 Days Ago
275 Ocean Ave is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Islip neighborhood of Islip. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, and outdoor space. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$3,850
3 Bedrooms · 2 Bathrooms Apartment · North Bay Shore, North Bay Shore
5+ Days Ago
1553 Potter Blvd ##1 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the North Bay Shore neighborhood of North Bay Shore. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$3,800
4 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Brentwood, Brentwood
5+ Days Ago
82 Yankee St is a 4 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Brentwood neighborhood of Brentwood. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$1,250
Studio · 1 Bathroom Apartment · West Islip, West Islip
2 Days Ago
202 W 1st St #RIGHT is a studio, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the West Islip neighborhood of West Islip. It has apartment amenities including outdoor space. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
Short stay
$1,500
1 Bedroom · 1 Bathroom Apartment · West Islip, West Islip
2 Days Ago
202 W 1st St is a 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the West Islip neighborhood of West Islip. It has apartment amenities including garage parking, outdoor space, and on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
Online toursAge restricted
$2,800
2 Bedrooms Apartment · Islip, Islip
Greenview Village I 55+ Nikia Dr is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Islip neighborhood of Islip. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
Luxury
Verified
$2,250–$3,950
Studio–3 Bedrooms Apartments · Hauppauge, Hauppauge
Renaissance Hills 1710 Devonshire Rd is an apartment rental building with 11 floorplans, and studio–3 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Hauppauge neighborhood of Hauppauge. It has building amenities including fitness center, swimming pool, outdoor space, on-site management, storage, and on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
$3,300–$3,900
2 Bedrooms Apartments · Central Islip, Central Islip
The Villas on Eastview 725 Eastview Dr is an apartment rental building with 4 floorplans, and 2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Central Islip neighborhood of Central Islip. It has building amenities including residents lounge, swimming pool, fitness center, and controlled access. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
$2,725–$4,000
Studio–2 Bedrooms Apartments · Oakdale, Oakdale
Brand New 62+ Luxury Apartment Residences 4180 Sunrise Hwy is an apartment rental building with 27 floorplans, and studio–2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Oakdale neighborhood of Oakdale. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
$1,200
1 Bedroom · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Central Islip, Central Islip
3 Days Ago
67 Adams Rd is a 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Central Islip neighborhood of Central Islip. It has apartment amenities including garage parking. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$3,000
2 Bedrooms · 1 Bathroom Apartment · Lindenhurst, Lindenhurst
5+ Days Ago
150 N Delaware Ave is a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment for rent. It is located in the Lindenhurst neighborhood of Lindenhurst. It has apartment amenities including on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
$10,000
4 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms Apartment · Oak Beach - Captree, Oak Beach-Captree
5+ Days Ago
11 Captree Is is a 4 bedroom, 4 bathrooms apartment for rent. It is located in the Oak Beach - Captree neighborhood of Oak Beach-Captree. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly apartment. View apartment
Online toursAge restricted
$1,915–$2,405
1 Bedroom Apartment · Lindenhurst, Lindenhurst
Bunt Commons I: 55+ Senior Living Community 150 N Broadway is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 1 bedroom units available. It is located in the Lindenhurst neighborhood of Lindenhurst. It has building amenities including residents lounge, fitness center, storage, and on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
Age restricted
$3,350
2 Bedrooms Apartment · Great River, Great River
Westbrook Green 55+ 5300 Westbrook Blvd is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Great River neighborhood of Great River. It has building amenities including residents lounge, outdoor space, fitness center, and swimming pool. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
Online toursAge restricted
$2,800
2 Bedrooms Apartment · West Babylon, West Babylon
Platt Gardens Adult Community 101 Platt Avenue ##132 is an apartment rental building with 1 floorplan, and 2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the West Babylon neighborhood of West Babylon. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
Verified
Online tours$2,780–$6,992
2–3 Bedrooms Apartments · Huntington Station, Huntington Station
Eagle Rock Apartments at Huntington Station 156 E Pulaski Rd is an apartment rental building with 2 floorplans, and 2–3 bedrooms units available. It is located in the Huntington Station neighborhood of Huntington Station. It has building amenities including controlled access, on-site management, outdoor space, and on-site laundry. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
$3,310–$4,795
1–2 Bedrooms Apartments · South Farmingdale, South Farmingdale
Fairfield Metro At Farmingdale Village 148 S Front St is an apartment rental building with 16 floorplans, and 1–2 bedrooms units available. It is located in the South Farmingdale neighborhood of South Farmingdale. It has building amenities including elevator, ev charging, swimming pool, controlled access, business center, residents lounge, fitness center, on-site laundry, garage parking, and outdoor space. Cats and dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly building. View building
That's All Folks!
We’re out of listings matching your filters. Want more results?
Modify Filters or Start a New Search