3 Shelter Island Ave · Apartment for Rent

Property Status: Active Welcome to 3 Shelter Island Avenue, a captivating residence nestled within the exclusive waterfront community of North Haven Manor in Sag Harbor, NY. This cozy home offers a total of 6 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms perfect for an unforgettable family vacation. Originally constructed in the 1700s, this historic home has been meticulously expanded, renovated, and lovingly maintained, seamlessly blending timeless charm with modern comforts. As you enter, you'll be greeted by entertaining spaces, including a sunroom and a screened-in porch with a projection screen for unforgettable summer outdoor movie nights. The property boasts a heated pool, complemented by an entertainment pool house featuring a convenient kitchenette, half bath, and an outdoor shower, offering the perfect setting for leisurely gatherings and relaxation. Additionally, the backyard presents a small basketball court and a fire pit, creating an inviting outdoor oasis. For outdoor enthusiasts, this home provides access to Sag Harbor Bay, complete with a paddle board and kayak for exploring the serene waters. Situated just minutes from the charming village of Sag Harbor and the Shelter Island ferry, this residence offers both tranquility and convenience. Office Phone: (516) 729-5595 Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.